Mystery Meat Chili

The other day, my good neighbor, Randy, handed my husband an unmarked, frozen bag of meat.
Randy said, "Tell Jill to make a pot of chili with this!"
Naturally, Charlie comes in relaying the message. When I asked him what type of meat it was,
Charlie said, "Randy didn't say."
Okay then.
My only clue was from the packaging. It was wrapped in the familiar one-pound bag you get from the local meat processor. Do you know these bags? On the front, there are printed boxes the processor checks to identify the meat; buffulo, elk, antelope and moose. None of the boxes were checked.
After I defrosted the mystery meat, I couldn't tell from its dark, rich color, nor from the clean aroma, what type of meat I had to work with. I wasn't worried too much about it, though. It was obviously fresh and lean, with the darkest crimson color. I knew right away, it was going to be good. I proceeded to cook it as if it were fresh, ground beef.
HERE'S WHAT I DID
- 1 pound LEAN ground mystery meat
- 2 teaspoons Mexican oregano
- 1 teaspoon cumin
- 1 1/2 teaspoons salt
- 1/4 teaspoon fresh black pepper
- 1 medium yellow onion, chopped
- 1 green bell pepper, roughly chopped
- 2 teaspoons dried garlic powder
- 1 (28 oz) can plum tomatoes, blending into a chunky sauce with a hand blender
- 2 cups chicken broth or water
- 2 cups cooked pinto beans
- grated cheese for topping
Use a large pot or dutch oven to brown the mystery meat with the oregano, salt and pepper, over medium heat. When the meat is cooked and there's no pink, add in the chopped onion, bell pepper. Cook until vegetables have softened, 7 to 10 minutes.
Next, add in the garlic powder, blended chunky tomato sauce, and broth. Bring to a boil, then REDUCE heat to a low simmer and cook for a good 40 minutes. If the chili looks too thick for your liking, then add a little extra broth or water. Top each bowl with grated cheese and serve with home baked cornbread or good ol'saltine crackers.
_______________
BACK TO MY STORY
After letting my chili bowl cool down a little, I took a big spoonful into my mouth. I was nervous all of a sudden. Chewing, chewing, waiting for a gamey flavor, waiting for the texture to reveal itself.
Nothing. Turns out, I'm not a meat connoisseur. I did pick up that it had a minute grainy texture. It wasn't distracting or weird, just mildly noticeable.
About that time, our good friends, Kim and Eli came over. You know them right? She's the one that's the Dietitian down at the hospital and my closest friend, and Eli is my son's bestest friend in the whole wide world. If any body could solve the mystery meat riddle, Kim and Eli could surely do it. They love exploring foods and will try ANYTHING, and I mean ANYTHING, at least once.
I watched their faces as they dove into their bowls. Kim guessed it was venison. Eli said it tasted like wild pig.
We devoured that chili after two meals, it was that good. And I still don't know the source of the mystery meat. I've been so incredibly busy, I haven't had the chance to walk over to Randy's to find out.
What do you guess we ate?





Not sure what you got (Hope you will update us) but my wife did mystery meat chili recently too. Turned out, it wasn’t meat at all, but vegetarian meat crumbles (Soy protein) and despite being a confirmed carnivore, I didn’t notice the difference when I ate it! (Sure, NOW I can talk about slightly different consistency, and a minor loss in meat flavor, but when I was eating it the first time….)
Just a thought for a simple, and easy way to replace ground beef in things like Chili or Spaghetti Sauce to reduce fat and calories without losing protein. (And really, unless you have a very refined palate or are seriously looking for differences I dont think you will notice a loss or lack of flavor or anything in these type of uses)
Tim Mead
Hey Tim! I know that vegetarian meat crumble you’re talking about. We used to eat it back in our college days when we had our vegetarian friends over for dinner. I would use it for my Camp Burrito recipe. Smother in bean sauce, it’s hard to tell a difference for meat eaters.
I only wish my family were that adventurous! Half of us are vegetarians, and the other are very finicky meatatarians. Maybe I could pull one over on them…hmmm…it is suppose to be cold in FLA this weekend!! Perfect for Mystery Meat Chili…huh?
I don’t know, but I’m dying to find out!
Where can I find this soy protien vegetarian meat crumbles?
Hi Dian!
You can find it in the freezer section with the vegetarian burritos, corn dogs and bean burgers at Whole Foods, Brookshires, and Central Market. Its been around for years, its NOT an exclusive item only found in health food stores. My own small town Brookshires carries vegetarian meat crumbles in the frozen organic/veggie section.
It generally comes in a one-pound bag. There are different brands, but its been so long since I’ve purchased any, I can’t tell you which tastes the best. You’ll have to come back and tell me. ;D
I FINALLY, FINALLY had the chance to ask Randy what type of meat was it that he gave me!
It was Venison!
Kim hit the nail right on the head. It sure was delicious and I wouldn’t hesitate to serve it up again.